Listen to this article
Estimated 4 minutes
The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Mispronunciations can occur. We are working with our partners to continually review and improve the results.
Brayden Schenn was familiar with the impressive plays.
The seasoned forward was well-acquainted with the buzz surrounding a young New York Islanders defenseman’s astonishing debut season, having observed it remotely.
Having joined the team before the NHL trade deadline, Schenn now has an up-close perspective.
Matthew Schaefer, a cheerful adolescent characterized by a broad grin and appealing demeanor, has emerged prominently, showcasing fluid skating, a powerful shot, and an exceptional understanding of hockey.
“He lives up to expectations,” commented Schenn, who arrived from the St. Louis Blues on March 6, referring to the remarkable 18-year-old. “Extremely talented, highly driven to excel. He possesses a unique character. He genuinely values his teammates.”
The club, moreover, considers itself lucky to have him.
“I prefer not to consider it,” responded Islanders head coach Patrick Roy when queried about imagining the team without Schaefer. “He has profoundly benefited our squad… frequently, the saying goes, ‘Defensemen require more time to mature.’ He has navigated those challenges exceptionally.”
As the clear frontrunner for the Calder Trophy recognizing the top rookie, Schaefer is also anticipated to receive nominations for the Norris Trophy (best defenseman) and Hart Trophy (most valuable player) for a season where the projected first overall selection in the 2025 draft accumulated 49 points (20 goals, 29 assists) over 68 matchups, simultaneously leading New York in ice time with over 24 minutes per game.
“My focus is on our collective efforts here,” he stated regarding his mindset. “It’s not merely about my individual performance; it’s about our group. We possess an excellent team. My teammates have provided immense support.”
“I strive for flawlessness and aim for perfection. However, true perfection is unattainable.”
Schaefer, who experienced the loss of his mother, Jennifer, to cancer in 2024 and was visibly moved on a poignant draft evening, has performed exceptionally well in his inaugural year. The Islanders, furthermore, were unaware of the full extent of his capabilities for the current season when training camp commenced.
Poised to surpass the team’s rookie defenseman scoring record (56 points), the player from Hamilton participated in only 17 contests during the 2024-25 season with the OHL’s Erie Otters and appeared in two additional games at the world junior hockey championship prior to fracturing his collarbone.
“We were aware of his inherent ability and his character,” remarked Roy, whose squad held third place in the Metropolitan Division with a 39-24-5 standing before Wednesday’s games. “His potential was significantly high.”
‘His fellow players admire him,’ states Brayden Schenn
Beyond his exceptional offensive skills, Schaefer has rapidly assimilated defensive strategies at the pinnacle of the sport, partnering with seasoned defenseman Ryan Pulock, who is nearly 13 years older.
“He maintains excellent spacing and possesses an adept stick,” Roy observed. “While his attacking prowess was known, his defensive performance has been remarkably noteworthy.”
A comparable sentiment resonated elsewhere within Scotiabank Arena during the current week.
“He is accomplishing feats achieved by very few players,” stated Toronto Maple Leafs center John Tavares, who began his league career as a teenager after being drafted first overall by New York in 2009. “He is more than just a cornerstone player… he has undoubtedly established himself as a talent of generational caliber.”
“It has been extraordinary.”
His conduct away from the rink is equally noteworthy.
“Completely authentic,” Schenn described Schaefer’s conduct and interactions with others. “Genuine in his self-presentation. It’s clear why his fellow players hold him in such high regard.”
Schaefer mentioned that besides managing demanding travel and understanding proper readiness, a significant adaptation involved modifying his strategies against larger, more powerful, and quicker adversaries.
“One must be aware of the players present on the ice,” he commented. “And certainly remain vigilant, as opponents are constantly challenging you.”
Schaefer, for his part, is just beginning his ascent.
“His development, his trajectory,” Schenn remarked. “The Islanders franchise and its supporters are entirely justified in their anticipation.”
