The period between seasons frequently resembles a massive round of musical chairs. Once franchises recover from the previous campaign, they shift their focus toward future development. Throughout this preparation phase, organizations leverage free agency, the annual draft, and various trades to upgrade their rosters, leading to a drastically transformed league landscape from one season to the next.
Considering this, and with the 2026 campaign approaching, we take this opportunity to assess the current state of every NFL roster based on paper projections. In the breakdown below, Jordan Dajani and Tyler Sullivan from CBS Sports analyze each franchise’s depth chart to evaluate and rank their projected starting lineups. Additionally, they highlight a key strength, a notable weakness, and a major unresolved question for each team. Below is the initial segment of their rankings, spanning from 32nd down to 17th.
32. Miami Dolphins
Depth Chart
The good: Running backs — Establishing himself as an elite backfield option in the league, De’Von Achane paced all rushers last year with an impressive 5.7 yards per attempt. His historical career average of 5.62 yards per carry ranks second all-time for his position. While Achane is slated to anchor the ground attack, the backfield features other compelling options. Jaylen Wright offers blistering speed, having clocked a 4.38-second 40-yard dash during the combine, whereas Ollie Gordon III provides a more muscular presence—carrying an extra 20 pounds compared to Achane and Wright—without sacrificing athleticism.
The bad: Secondary — The secondary for the Dolphins currently projects as the weakest unit in the NFL. The preliminary depth chart features JuJu Brents, Jason Marshall Jr., and first-year player Chris Johnson as the main cornerbacks, with Dante Trader Jr. and Zayne Anderson occupying the safety slots. Though expected to contribute, both Darrell Baker Jr. and Storm Duck are currently recovering from physical setbacks.
The question: Quarterback — The stage is set for Malik Willis to demonstrate his potential as a true franchise signal-caller. Selected in the third round out of Liberty, he showed flashes of brilliance during his limited time in Green Bay, despite only getting the nod to start three times. His standout performance came in a single start against Baltimore last year, where he connected on 18 of 21 throws for 288 yards and a touchdown, while additionally pacing the ground game with 60 rushing yards and two scores. The big question is whether he is on the cusp of stardom.
31. Arizona Cardinals
Depth Chart
The good: Tight end — Following his stellar 2025 performance, Trey McBride is firmly in the conversation as the league’s premier tight end. At 26 years old, he hauled in 126 passes for 1,239 yards and hit paydirt 11 times. That catch total set a historic single-season high for tight ends. He remains the focal point of the Cardinals’ aerial strategy.
The bad: Quarterback — With the team parting ways with Kyler Murray, Jacoby Brissett is positioned to take over under center. Even though Brissett recorded respectable statistics over 12 starts in 2025, those efforts yielded a dismal 1-11 record. To prepare for the future, the front office selected Carson Beck early in the third round of the 2026 draft. Although they will likely hand the reins to the rookie at some point to evaluate him, he is not currently projected as a long-term franchise savior.
The question: Running back — At first, Arizona’s running game appeared to be a formidable asset, particularly after investing the third overall selection in Jeremiyah Love. Unfortunately, Love’s status for the season opener is now in jeopardy due to a high ankle sprain. Although they brought in experienced runner Tyler Allgeier during free agency, their overall depth is thin because James Conner is also rehabbing an ankle issue. If Love recovers in time for kickoff, the backfield should perform well, but the current injury situation presents major concerns.
30. Cleveland Browns
Depth Chart
The good: Front seven — While we could easily highlight the entire defensive unit, we will focus specifically on the formidable front seven. Even in the absence of Myles Garrett, Cleveland boasts an impressive lineup. Top draft pick Mason Graham anchors the middle alongside Maliek Collins, with Jared Verse generating pressure from the outside. Although Alex Wright was lost to a ruptured Achilles, the front office signed former first-rounder Derek Barnett to bolster their depth.
Despite being new to the squad, Verse—a two-time Pro Bowl selection and past Defensive Rookie of the Year—has stepped up as a vocal leader. The linebacker corps features experienced defender Quincy Williams, the relatively unproven Easton Mascarenas-Arnold, and the latest Defensive Rookie of the Year, Carson Schwesinger. Remarkably, this defense features the league’s last two top defensive rookies side-by-side.
The bad: Quarterback — Cleveland’s quarterback situation might be the most concerning in the league. Since arriving via trade from Houston, Deshaun Watson has struggled immensely, posting the lowest marks in completion rate, average yards per pass, and touchdown-to-interception margin among starters. Meanwhile, Shedeur Sanders topped the league in picks following his late-season debut in Week 11, recording a second-to-last completion rate of 57% and a weak 68.1 passer rating. Nevertheless, Watson retains the starting job for the time being.
The question: Offensive line — Cleveland has achieved the dubious distinction of being the sole franchise since 1970 to replace all five starting offensive linemen in a single offseason. This group struggled mightily and faced heavy injuries in 2025, raising the ultimate question: can the newly formed line protect the quarterback? The projected lineup features rookie first-rounder Spencer Fano at left tackle, Zion Johnson at left guard, veteran Elgton Jenkins at center, Teven Jenkins at right guard, and Tytus Howard securing the right tackle spot.
29. Atlanta Falcons
Depth Chart
The good: Running back — Naturally, Bijan Robinson is the main attraction. The elite playmaker heads into 2026 as arguably the most dominant back in football after securing a lucrative three-year, $66.8 million contract extension. Robinson topped the league last year with 2,298 yards from scrimmage and scored 11 touchdowns. His cumulative 5,648 scrimmage yards rank fourth all-time for any player over their first three NFL seasons. While Robinson will carry the bulk of the workload, the backup options are solid. To replace Tyler Allgeier, who departed for Arizona, Atlanta secured Brian Robinson Jr. on a one-year contract, providing a former starter as a high-quality secondary option.
The bad: Edge rushers — The Falcons’ edge rush originally appeared to be a major strength after they secured both Jalon Walker and James Pearce Jr. in the first round of the 2025 draft. Sadly, both of those cornerstones will be unavailable for significant portions of 2026. Walker’s season ended prematurely with an ACL tear in training camp, while Pearce was handed an eight-game ban for violating personal conduct guidelines. These setbacks forced management to turn to free agency, enticing 33-year-old veteran Za’Darius Smith to return to the gridiron.
The question: Quarterback — An intriguing quarterback competition is underway in Atlanta between last year’s starter Michael Penix Jr. and newcomer Tua Tagovailoa, who joined on a one-year contract after being cut by Miami. Penix has finally received medical clearance for full-team drills as he rehabs a torn ACL, while Tagovailoa has not yet secured the definitive starting role. If Tagovailoa claims the job, can he revitalize his career in a new system, or will his struggles persist? Conversely, if Penix commands the offense, can he avoid further injuries and elevate his efficiency? The Falcons have heavily upgraded their offensive weapons, but those moves require consistent play at quarterback to bear fruit.
28. Tennessee Titans
Depth Chart
The good: Wide receiver — Time will tell regarding their ultimate ceiling, but this stands out as perhaps the most deep-seated group of wide receivers in franchise history. General manager Mike Borgonzi brought in Ohio State star Carnell Tate with the fourth overall selection in the 2026 draft, and locked up Wan’Dale Robinson with a four-year contract. Robinson accumulated 1,014 receiving yards last year with the Giants, setting a modern record for pass-catchers under 5-foot-9.
The Titans also have Calvin Ridley, who has reached 1,000 receiving yards in each of the last three seasons in which he played at least eight games. Plus, some talented second-year pass-catchers in Elic Ayomanor, who has been making waves in training camp after catching 41 passes for 515 yards and four touchdowns as a rookie, and Chimere Dike, who was named a First Team All-Pro last year as a returner after breaking the NFL rookie record for most all-purpose yards. That’s a solid five right there.
The bad: Offensive line — Tennessee’s offensive line has struggled to protect and block for several consecutive seasons. Left guard Peter Skoronski, fresh off securing a historic, record-breaking contract, represents the only elite piece. Left tackle Dan Moore Jr. has disappointed relative to the $82 million investment made last year, and right tackle JC Latham has failed to justify his status as a former top-ten pick. To shore up the middle, the team brought in Austin Schlottmann at center, while rookie fifth-rounder Fernando Carmona is currently projected to secure the starting right guard spot.
The question: Quarterback — Evaluating Cam Ward’s debut season is a complicated task. His initial stretch was rough, producing only five scores against 11 giveaways in his first nine starts, before he stabilized to record 12 touchdowns and a mere three turnovers during his remaining games. The team lacked offensive identity in 2025, but the arrival of Robert Saleh as head coach and Brian Daboll to orchestrate the offense should change that. The primary question is whether Ward can master this new system, refine his accuracy, and make smart decisions when plays break down. If he takes a significant step forward, this 28th ranking will look far too conservative.
27. Las Vegas Raiders
Depth Chart
The good: Tight end — Both Kirk Cousins and Fernando Mendoza will benefit from an exciting group of tight ends. Brock Bowers is far more than a simple safety valve; the dynamic playmaker projects as the Raiders’ primary aerial threat if he remains healthy. Meanwhile, former second-round selection Michael Mayer remains a reliable target, as evidenced by his early preseason scoring. Veteran Ian Thomas and Albert Okwuegbunam Jr. round out a very deep unit.
The bad: Wide receiver — Vegas featured one of the league’s least productive receiver rooms last season, and their offseason additions were limited to Jalen Nailor and rookie Malik Benson. While Tre Tucker returns after leading the squad with 696 yards and five touchdowns, the team is relying heavily on rapid development from sophomores Jack Bech and Dont’e Thornton Jr. Bowers will carry a heavy load in the passing game, but the overall talent at wide receiver remains highly suspect.
The question: Offensive line — The offensive line ranked dead last in the NFL last season, though they have attempted to rebuild by signing center Tyler Linderbaum and left guard Spencer Burford. Linderbaum set records as the most expensive interior lineman in free agency history at $27 million annually, while Burford brings championship experience from San Francisco. Whether these moves will elevate the protection remains to be seen, but improvement is vital for the quarterbacks to perform.
26. New York Jets
Depth Chart
The good: Wide receivers — The Jets have quietly put together a very intriguing group of wide receivers. Garrett Wilson is the clear headliner and remains an elite route-runner despite enduring inconsistent quarterback play, looking to rebound from an injury-shortened 2025 season. Alongside him, Adonai Mitchell—acquired in the blockbuster trade involving Sauce Gardner—exhibited significant promise last year. Additionally, rookie first-rounder Omar Cooper Jr. enters the mix after finishing second in the Big Ten with 13 receiving scores. This represents a highly talented group if the passing game can deliver.
The bad: Quarterback — The reunion of Geno Smith with the Jets is unlikely to inspire immense confidence. Though he revived his career with the Seahawks, his subsequent stint in Las Vegas was marked by a league-high 17 interceptions. While his veteran presence should lift a passing offense that ranked dead last with just 140.3 yards per game last year, his presence limits the unit’s overall potential.
The question: Pass rush — While the failure to secure a single interception last year drew headlines, the underlying issue was a non-existent pass rush. The Jets finished last in pressure rate at 28% and recorded the second-fewest sacks in the league. To address this glaring weakness, the front office spent the second overall draft pick on elite edge defender David Bailey and signed Joseph Ossai to a lucrative $36 million contract. If these additions can successfully disrupt opposing passers, the secondary might finally start forcing mistakes.
25. New Orleans Saints
Depth Chart
The good: Offensive line — New Orleans has put together a highly capable starting offensive line to shield Tyler Shough. According to analytics from PFF, left tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. stood out as the league’s top rookie blocker last year. He is joined by free-agent acquisition David Edwards at left guard, with two-time Pro Bowl center Erik McCoy anchoring the middle. While Cesar Ruiz remains inconsistent at right guard, talented former first-rounder Taliese Fuaga could excel at right tackle if he stays healthy. Though overall depth is a concern, the starting front five is quite competitive.
The bad: Special teams — The third phase of the game was a major liability for New Orleans in 2025, and issues seem to linger. The team signed former Vikings punter Ryan Wright to a $14 million contract, but his debut included an embarrassing 15-yard shank, though he recovered in subsequent action. Field goal kicking was equally problematic, with a combined success rate of just 71.4% that ranked near the bottom of the league. After a lackluster preseason battle between Tanner Brown and Charlie Smyth, the front office signed veteran Daniel Carlson to stabilize the position.
The question: Weaponry — While the skill positions could be a major strength, early setbacks complicate the outlook, with star back Alvin Kamara and rookie receiver Jordyn Tyson both sidelined for several weeks. This leaves Chris Olave to carry the passing game once more, while raising questions about whether Travis Etienne Jr. can justify his current deal. If this offensive group can stay healthy, Shough will have plenty of targets, but durability remains the ultimate key to New Orleans’ sleeper potential.
24. Carolina Panthers
Depth Chart
The good: Cornerbacks- The cornerback tandem of Jaycee Horn and Mike Jackson gives Carolina a very reliable duo. Horn enters the season coming off consecutive Pro Bowl selections and a career-best five interceptions, while the underrated Jackson finished tied for the league lead with 19 pass breakups alongside four interceptions of his own.
The bad: Tight end — The search for a dynamic tight end has plagued the Panthers for several seasons. Despite draft investments in Tommy Tremble, Ja’Tavion Sanders, and Mitchell Evans, none have developed into reliable receiving options. The team’s desperation at the position is highlighted by their recent signing of veteran Darren Waller, who is nearing his 34th birthday.
The question: Offensive line — Losing both starting tackles ahead of the opener would devastate most offenses, but Carolina is testing its depth. Free-agent pickup Rasheed Walker is set to protect the blindside in place of Ickey Ekwonu, while rookie Monroe Freeling steps in for Taylor Moton on the right. With Luke Fortner also taking over at center, the line features three new starters. If they can build chemistry quickly, the offense should remain stable, but it is a massive question mark.
23. New York Giants
Depth Chart
The good: Pass rushers — Disrupting opposing quarterbacks should be the primary strength of the Giants’ defense. Brian Burns put up elite numbers last season, ranking among the top defenders in sacks, hits, and tackles for loss, while sophomore edge rusher Abdul Carter finished his rookie year strong. With Kayvon Thibodeaux and rookie linebacker Arvell Reese also in the mix, this pass rush has the potential to be incredibly disruptive.
The bad: Defensive interior — Following the departure of Dexter Lawrence II, New York must rely on Shelby Harris, DJ Reader, and Darius Alexander to hold down the defensive interior. This is a massive concern for a defense that surrendered a league-worst 5.3 yards per carry last year. Reader remains an effective space-eater but is now 32 and coming off a sack-less season, while Harris is 35 and on a managed workload. Alexander has yet to show much promise, leaving the run defense highly vulnerable.
The question: Quarterback — While Jaxson Dart brings an exciting dual-threat skill set, questions remain about his long-term efficiency and durability. He joined elite company by recording double-digit passing scores and eight rushing touchdowns as a rookie, but his physical play style has led to frequent injuries. To take the next step, he must improve his 63.7% completion rate and prove he can win consistently from the pocket.
22. Washington Commanders
Depth Chart
The good: Quarterback — Jayden Daniels enjoyed an historic rookie season, leading Washington to an NFC Championship game appearance and a 12-5 record. He became just the second player ever to exceed 4,000 passing yards and 1,000 rushing yards in a single year while setting a rookie touchdown record. However, keeping him healthy is paramount after a series of injuries sidelined him for 10 games last year, causing the team to slide to 5-12. While Marcus Mariota provides a high-end backup option, Washington’s success rests entirely on their young star’s availability.
The bad: Cornerback — The depth and talent in Washington’s cornerback room raise immediate red flags. The projected starting lineup features Trey Amos, who is coming off a broken leg, alongside former Lions defender Amik Robertson and the undersized Mike Sainristil. While veteran Rasul Douglas offers some stability, this group remains highly susceptible to opposing passing attacks.
The question: Left side of the offensive line — Following a season-ending injury to star tackle Laremy Tunsil, the Commanders are trusting Brandon Coleman to secure the blindside. Coleman had been competing for the starting guard spot, meaning his transition to tackle leaves left guard in the hands of Chris Paul. Whether this rearranged left side can hold up under pressure will dictate the success of the entire offense.
21. Indianapolis Colts
Depth Chart
The good: Offensive line — When healthy, Indianapolis features an offensive line capable of dominating the conference. Bernhard Raimann anchors the left side alongside elite guard Quenton Nelson, while sophomore center Tanor Bortolini has quickly developed into an efficient blocker. With Matt Goncalves and Jalen Travis completing the right side, the Colts boast a formidable front five.
The bad: Linebacker — The loss of Zaire Franklin leaves a massive void at linebacker, which the Colts hope rookie CJ Allen can fill. While Allen possesses great physical traits, relying on a first-year player alongside veteran journeyman Akeem Davis-Gaither could lead to major inconsistencies in the middle of the defense.
The question: Wide receiver — Instead of focusing on the quarterback, the wide receiver room deserves closer scrutiny. Indianapolis made a massive financial commitment to Alec Pierce, but he has yet to prove he can be a true focal point while dealing with nagging injuries. The addition of veteran Keenan Allen provides experience, but his age is a factor, while Josh Downs remains an inconsistent secondary option. If this group fails to generate consistent separation, the offense will struggle to sustain drives.
20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Depth Chart
The good: Defensive line — Following a contract resolution with Vita Vea, Tampa Bay retains an elite defensive line. Vea remains a dominant interior force, paired alongside Calijah Kancey, who is eager to bounce back after injuries ruined his 2025 season. Supported by edge rushers Yaya Diaby and rookie first-rounder Rueben Bain Jr., this defensive front should consistently disrupt opposing offenses.
The bad: Cornerback — Following the departure of Jamel Dean, the Buccaneers must rely on Zyon McCollum and sophomore Benjamin Morrison at cornerback. Morrison struggled with injuries and surrendered a high passer rating in limited action as a rookie, while McCollum has shown vulnerability in coverage, giving up six touchdowns last season.
The question: Quarterback — Heading into a critical contract season, Baker Mayfield’s performance will dictate the Buccaneers’ fortunes. If he can recapture the form that had him in early MVP conversations last year before injuries derailed the season, Tampa Bay will remain highly competitive in the division.
19. Pittsburgh Steelers
Depth Chart
The good: Edge rusher — Pittsburgh’s defense is built around its relentless pass rush. T.J. Watt continues to terrorize opposing tackles, while Alex Highsmith and rising star Nick Herbig provide elite complementary pressure from the opposite side, making this one of the most dangerous edge units in football.
The bad: Safety — The safety position is plagued by severe durability concerns and a lack of proven depth. Projected starters Jaquan Brisker and DeShon Elliott both have extensive injury histories, leaving the secondary highly vulnerable should either miss significant time.
The question: Quarterback — With Aaron Rodgers set to retire after this campaign, the Steelers must determine how much the 42-year-old veteran has left in the tank. While he avoided turnovers last year, his efficiency metrics were average, raising questions about whether he can elevate this offense to postseason contention.
18. Minnesota Vikings
Depth Chart
The good: Wide receiver — Minnesota features an incredible collection of receiving talent to support Kyler Murray. Justin Jefferson remains arguably the league’s top receiver, while Jordan Addison serves as an elite secondary target. The addition of former 49er Jauan Jennings provides an exceptional third option who excels in high-pressure situations and third-down conversions.
The bad: Safety — The departure of Harrison Smith marks the end of an era, leaving Minnesota with an unproven safety tandem. While Joshua Metellus is a reliable tackler, projected starter Jay Ward has very little starting experience, placing immense pressure on rookie Jakobe Thomas to develop quickly.
The question: Quarterback — If Kyler Murray can revitalize his career under Kevin O’Connell and stay healthy, the Vikings could surprise many. However, his injury history and recent struggles in Arizona mean he has a lot to prove in this new system.
17. Chicago Bears
Depth Chart
The good: Tight end — Sophomore tight end Colston Loveland is poised for a massive breakout season after showing elite receiving ability down the stretch of his rookie year. Paired with reliable veteran Cole Kmet and rookie draft pick Sam Roush, the Bears feature one of the most dynamic tight end rooms in the NFL.
The bad: Center — The unexpected retirement of center Drew Dalman dealt a severe blow to the offensive line’s stability. While guards Joe Thuney and Jonah Jackson remain elite, the transition to veteran Garrett Bradbury or rookie Logan Jones at center raises serious protection concerns.
The question: Wide receiver — After trading away star receiver DJ Moore, Chicago’s passing attack relies heavily on young wideouts Rome Odunze and Luther Burden III. While both possess immense talent, they must prove they can handle the demands of being primary targets for Caleb Williams.
